How to Choose the Best Insert for Comfort & Style

One Affirmation
Decorative throw pillows styled with plush  pillow inserts on a neutral sofa in a modern living room.

Learn about different pillow insert types and how to choose the right size and fill for comfort, style, and durability. A simple guide for better looking throw pillows.

Choosing the right pillow insert can completely change how your space looks and feels. A beautiful pillow cover can fall flat if the insert inside isn’t right, while the right insert creates that full, designer-worthy look everyone wants.

In this guide, we’ll break down the most common pillow insert types, how to choose the best size and fill, and simple styling tips to help your throw pillows look polished, comfortable, and intentional, without overspending.

Table of Contents

1. Types of Pillow Inserts

When selecting a pillow insert, consider factors like fill material, firmness, and size. Here’s a breakdown of the common types:

  • Feather/Down Inserts: Known for their luxurious softness and ability to mold to your shape, feather/down inserts like our 100% Down Pillow Inserts offer exceptional comfort. They tend to flatten faster, so choose a slightly larger size for a more plush look. Best for sofas, beds, and spaces where you want a relaxed, high end look.
  • Synthetic Inserts: A great alternative for those with allergies, synthetic inserts provide a hypoallergenic solution. They offer good support but might lack the same plush feel as down. A practical option for family homes, guest rooms, and allergy-sensitive spaces.
  • Foam Inserts: With a more structured form, foam inserts are ideal for spaces needing a modern edge or for those pillows that are more for display than comfort. Ideal for accent pillows that are more decorative than functional.

2. Practical Styling Advice

When it comes to styling with pillow inserts, balance and proportion are key.

Size and Placement

Start by selecting the right size for your pillow covers. For example, a 20x20 insert should fit snug in a similar sized cover. To achieve a fuller look, consider sizing up your insert. Explore our Designer Throw Pillow Covers for covers that add character to your space.

Designer Tip: For a fuller, designer-style pillow, choose an insert 1-2 inches larger than your pillow cover. This prevents sagging corners and keeps pillows looking plush over time. 

Color and Texture

Mix and match textures and colors to create dynamic and inviting spaces. Nordic tones like the Speckled Pillow Cover in Navy Blue or vibrant colors as seen in the Asha Pillow Cover in Pink will offer visual interest and warmth.

3. Care and Maintenance

To maintain your pillow inserts:

  • Regularly fluff feather/down inserts to sustain their shape.
  • Wash synthetic inserts periodically following care label instructions.
  • Spot clean foam inserts, avoiding excess water.

Explore More

Discover more pillow varieties in our Pillow Cover Inserts Collection and elevate your home's comfort with carefully chosen accents.

Throw Pillow Quick Facts

  • Pillow to cover ratio: Use a slightly larger insert for a fuller look.
  • Feather/down for plush comfort, synthetic for allergies.
  • Size options commonly range from 18x18 to 26x26.
  • Layering involves mixing sizes and shapes like square, lumbar.
  • Bright covers add a pop; neutrals offer a minimalist look.
  • Regular fluffing keeps down inserts from going flat.
  • Rotate and flip inserts routinely for even wear.

Throw Pillow FAQs

Q: How often should I replace my pillow inserts?
A: Replace inserts every 3-5 years, or sooner if they lose shape or comfort.

Q: Can I mix different types of inserts?
A: Absolutely! Combining different inserts offers varied support and aesthetic appeal.

Q: Should pillow inserts be bigger than the cover?
A: Yes. Most designers recommend sizing up your insert by 1-2 inches for a fuller, more structured look.

Learn more and explore our range of pillow covers and inserts on One Affirmation.

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.